Products | The Proper Pet

Sort by

Clear Filters

Shopping for Store Pickup

Mad Cat Beach Babe Mouse Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$7.99

Add to cart

Mad Cat Shark Twisty Kicker Cat Toy

Plush & Mice Toys

$6.99

Add to cart

Mad Cat Mewnicorn Plush Cat Toy, 2-pack

Toys

$10.49

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Wee Chippie and His Acorn Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

KONG Active Curlz Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$6.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Bindies Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

R2P Pet Mad Cat Tabby Taco Cat Toy

Chasers & Teasers

$5.99

KONG Scrattles Chicken & Egg Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$5.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Wee Squooshie Mice Cat Toy

Toys

$11.99

Add to cart

Pet Shop by Fringe Studio Charged Up Cat Toy

Plush & Mice Toys

$6.99

Add to cart

Mad Cat Purrfect Pineapple Plush Cat Toy

Toys

$6.99

Mad Cat Sloth with Silvervine Stick Cat Toy

Toys

$5.99

Haute Diggity Dog Purrona Bottle & Ball Organic Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$12.99

Add to cart

Mad Cat Burrito Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy

Plush & Mice Toys

$10.49

Turbo Cat Toy, Assorted Colors

Plush & Mice Toys

$1.29

Add to cart

KONG Licks Kitty Cat Toy

Treat Toys

$6.99

Add to cart

Yeowww! Stinkies Catnip Cat Toy

Plush & Mice Toys

Starting at $3.29

Add to cart

KONG Signature Ball Dog Toy, 2-pack

Chew Toys

Starting at $9.99

Add to cart

Chilly Dog Wooly Mice Catnip Cat Toy

Plush & Mice Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Yeowww! Butterfly Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

Starting at $5.99

Add to cart

Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Dog Toy, 2 pack

Balls

$11.99

Add to cart

KONG Naturals Scratcher Cat Toy

Scratch Boxes

$7.99

Add to cart

Turbo Mop Mice Cat Toy, Assorted Colors

Plush & Mice Toys

$1.29

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Dust Bunnies Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Yeowww! Hearrrt Attack Catnip Cat Toy, YEOWWW!

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$8.99

Add to cart

Turbo Plush Monsters Cat Toy, Assorted Colors

Plush & Mice Toys

$1.69

Add to cart

Multipet Pizza Slice Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$1.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Ma-Cat-a-Roonies Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Ethical Pet Nest Scratcher Cat Toy

Scratchers

$25.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Chickies Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Yeowww! Mo Betta Fish Cat Toy, Red

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$8.99

Add to cart

Yeowww! Mo Betta Fish Cat Toy, Blue

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$8.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Sardinies Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Multipet Catnip Garden Bubbles Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$4.99

Add to cart

Ethical Pet Spot Slotted Balls Cat Toy

Balls

$4.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Fur Ballies Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Jellie Fish Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Made By Nacho Catnip & Passion Flower Blend Cat Treats

Catnip & Pet Grass Treats

$8.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Mightie Mice Cat Toy

Toys

$11.99

Add to cart

Original Territory Margarita 2-in-1 Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$11.99

Add to cart

Original Territory Hurricane 2-in-1 Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$11.99

Add to cart

Whimzees Natural Dental Chicken & Tuna Cat Treats

Crunchy Treats

$3.99

Add to cart

Multipet Two Tone Mesh Ball with Feather Cat Toy

Balls

$2.99

Add to cart

KONG Nibbies Chicken Cat Treats

Crunchy Treats

$4.99

Add to cart

Meowijuana Catnip & Honeysuckle Bubbles Bottle with Bubble Wand Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$7.99

Add to cart

1 2 3 ... 69 70 71 Next

Showing entries 1-45 of 3195.