Products | The Proper Pet

Sort by

Clear Filters

Shopping for Store Pickup

Multipet Felt Ball with Feather Cat Toy, Color Varies

Balls

$2.49

Add to cart

Multipet Candy Crackle with Feather Cat Toy, Color Varies

Toys

$1.99

Add to cart

Multipet Mice with Safari Feather Cat Toy, Color Varies

Plush & Mice Toys

$2.99

Add to cart

Multipet Pizza Slice Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$1.99

Add to cart

Multipet Catnip Garden Bubbles Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$4.99

Add to cart

Multipet Lamb Chop with Birthday Hat Dog Toy, Blue

Stuffed Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Ethical Pet Spot Cat-Bernet Cork with Feathers Teaser Wand Cat Toy, Color Varies

Chasers & Teasers

$6.99

Multipet Chilly Bone Dog Chew Toy

Chew Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

Starting at $9.99

Add to cart

Starmark Everlasting Bento Ball with Dental Treat Dog Chew Toy

Chew Toys

Starting at $12.99

Add to cart

Multipet Minipet Latex Pacifier Dog Toy

Toys

$3.99

Add to cart

KONG Active Feather Teaser Cat Toy, Color Varies

Chasers & Teasers

$8.99

Multipet Lamb Chop Squeaker Mat Dog Toy

Plush Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

KONG Signature Ball Dog Toy, 2-pack

Chew Toys

Starting at $9.99

Add to cart

KONG Blissy Moon Ball with Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$7.99

Chuckit! Ultra Rubber Ball Dog Toy, 2 pack

Balls

$11.99

Add to cart

Multipet Lamb Chop Dog Bed

Pillow Beds

$42.99

Add to cart

Haute Diggity Dog Purrona Bottle & Ball Organic Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$12.99

Add to cart

KONG Naturals Scratcher Cat Toy

Scratch Boxes

$7.99

Add to cart

Under the Weather Cat Urinary Support

Urinary & Kidney Health

$14.99

Add to cart

Multipet AromaDog Ring-Body Therapeutic Essential Oil Dog Toy, Assorted Colors

Stuffed Toys

$12.99

Add to cart

Mad Cat Beach Babe Mouse Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$7.99

Add to cart

Mammoth Flossy Chews Twister Pull Tug with Ball Dog Toy, Color Varies

Rope & Tug Toys

$7.99

Add to cart

Tall Tails Grizzly Head 2-in-1 Fetch Ball Dog Toy

Balls

$9.99

Add to cart

Tall Tails Gorilla Head 2-in-1 Fetch Ball Dog Toy

Balls

$9.99

Add to cart

Tall Tails Yeti Head 2-in-1 Fetch Ball Dog Toy

Balls

$9.99

Add to cart

Dogs in the Kitchen Fowl Ball with Chicken Breast & Turkey Au Jus Wet Dog Food Pouch

Wet Food

$1.79

Add to cart

Tall Tails Highland Cow Head 2-in-1 Fetch Ball Dog Toy

Balls, Stuffed Toys

$9.99

Add to cart

Tall Tails Black Bear Head 2-in-1 Fetch Ball Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys, Balls

$9.99

Add to cart

Arlee Max Fusion with Nike Grind Quantum Ball Dog Toy

Chew Toys, Treat Toys & Dispensers, Balls

$14.99

Add to cart

West Paw BOUNDR Ball Dog Toy, Glow, Small

Balls

$18.99

Add to cart

Turbo Scratcher Cat Toy Replacement Pads

Scratchers

$12.99

Arlee Max Fusion with Nike Grind Meteor Ball Dog Toy, Blue

Chew Toys, Balls

$19.99

Add to cart

Arlee Max Fusion with Nike Grind Meteor Ball Dog Toy, Yellow

Chew Toys, Balls

$12.99

Add to cart

West Paw BOUNDR Ball Dog Toy, Aqua/Dandelion, Small

Balls

$18.99

Add to cart

Mad Cat Shark Twisty Kicker Cat Toy

Plush & Mice Toys

$6.99

Add to cart

Petlou EZ Squeaky Ball Cow & Donkey Dog Toy, 4-in

Balls

$12.99

Add to cart

West Paw BOUNDR Ball Dog Toy, Dandelion/Hot Pink, Small

Balls

$18.99

Add to cart

West Paw BOUNDR Ball Dog Toy, Hot Pink/Aqua, Small

Balls

$18.99

Add to cart

Chuckit! Birthday Fetch Ball Dog Toy

Balls

$7.99

Add to cart

Fluff & Tuff Beach Ball Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$11.99

Add to cart

KONG Active Curlz Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$6.99

Add to cart

Chuckit! Super Crunch Ball Dog Toy

Balls

$11.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Wee Squooshie Mice Cat Toy

Toys

$11.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Bindies Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

1 2 3 ... 94 95 96 Next

Showing entries 1-45 of 4311.