Products | The Proper Pet

Sort by

Clear Filters

Shopping for Store Pickup

Trixie Activity Crazy Circle with Plush Mouse Cat Toy, Pink/White

Interactive Toys

$14.99

Add to cart

Trixie Activity Snack Play Junior Kitten Cat Toy

Treat Toys

$13.99

Add to cart

Mad Cat Beach Babe Mouse Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$7.99

Add to cart

Turbo Plush Monsters Cat Toy, Assorted Colors

Plush & Mice Toys

$1.69

Add to cart

KONG Snuzzles Mouse Cat Toy

Plush & Mice Toys

$5.99

Petstages Squeak Squeak Mouse Cat Toy, Grey

Plush & Mice Toys

$6.99

KONG Wubba Mouse Cat Toy, Color Varies

Plush & Mice Toys

$6.99

Sunseed Vita Rat & Mouse Diet

Mouse & Rat

$7.99

Add to cart

Fromm Family Gold Reduced Activity & Senior Dry Dog Food

Dry Food

Starting at $15.99

Add to cart

KONG Active Curlz Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$6.99

Add to cart

GoDog Silent Squeak Crazy Hair Elephant Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$14.99

Add to cart

Trixie Rocking Bowl Dog Slow Feeder

Slow Feeders

$17.99

Add to cart

Multipet Candy Crackle with Feather Cat Toy, Color Varies

Toys

$1.99

Add to cart

Meowijuana Catnip & Honeysuckle Bubbles Bottle with Bubble Wand Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$7.99

Add to cart

Oxbow Essentials Mouse & Young Rat Food

Mouse & Rat

$11.99

Add to cart

Haute Diggity Dog Birthday Boy Dog Plush Toy

Chew Toys, Plush Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Oxbow Enriched Life Natural Activity Mobile Small Animal Toy

Toys

$18.99

Stella & Chewy's Wild Weenies Bac'n Me Crazy Freeze-Dried Dog Treats

Freeze-Dried Treats

$14.99

Add to cart

Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

Starting at $9.99

Add to cart

Fussie Cat Fine Dining Mousse Sardine with Pumpkin Entree in Gravy Wet Cat Food Can

Wet Food

$1.19

Add to cart

fabdog Floppy Plush Dog Toy, Hippo

Plush Toys

$15.99

Add to cart

Outward Hound HedgehogZ Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$21.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Wee Squooshie Mice Cat Toy

Toys

$11.99

Add to cart

Multipet Mice with Safari Feather Cat Toy, Color Varies

Plush & Mice Toys

$2.99

Add to cart

Haute Diggity Dog Happy Birthday Bone Plush Dog Toy

Plush Toys, Chew Toys

$12.99

Add to cart

Outward Hound HedgehogZ Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

Starting at $5.99

Add to cart

Fluff & Tuff Basketball Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$19.99

Add to cart

Tall Tails Mini Yeti Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$17.99

Add to cart

Tall Tails Flying Pig Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$24.99

Add to cart

Tall Tails Bee Squeaker Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$11.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Wee Chippie and His Acorn Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

Fussie Cat Fine Dining Mousse Chicken with Pumpkin Entree in Gravy Wet Cat Food Can

Wet Food

$1.19

Add to cart

Fluff & Tuff Archie Red Panda Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$20.99

Add to cart

Tall Tails Jointed Shake Play Gator Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$17.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds HuggleKats Bindies Cat Toy

Toys

$10.99

Add to cart

KONG Scrattles Chicken & Egg Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$5.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds Maple Moose X-Brace Durable Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$26.99

Add to cart

Tall Tails Jointed Shake Play Shark Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$17.99

Add to cart

Fussie Cat Fine Dining Mousse Mackerel with Pumpkin Entree in Gravy Wet Cat Food Can

Wet Food

$1.19

Add to cart

Fussie Cat Fine Dining Mousse Tuna with Pumpkin Entree in Gravy Wet Cat Food Can

Wet Food

$1.19

Add to cart

Tall Tails Monarch Butterfly Squeaker Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$11.99

Add to cart

HuggleHounds Redwood Raccoon X-Brace Plush Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$26.99

Add to cart

Fussie Cat Fine Dining Mousse Ocean Fish with Pumpkin Entree in Gravy Wet Cat Food Can

Wet Food

$1.19

Add to cart

Haute Diggity Dog Purrona Bottle & Ball Organic Catnip Cat Toy

Catnip & Pet Grass Toys

$12.99

Add to cart

Huxley & Kent Power Plush Pup-Tarts Frosted Strawberry Dog Toy

Stuffed Toys

$15.99

Add to cart

1 2 3 ... 89 90 91 Next

Showing entries 1-45 of 4075.